The Sins That Cry for Vengeance: Season 1, Episode 4 “Pay Dearly”

A new ally in the plot helps you work out the next moves of a bigger scheme.

This episode has 8 choices, 4 of them paid.

The priciest pick is “Remember” for 31 diamonds.

You can play it free: every paid choice has a free option.

Romance steps here: Volpe — 1, Frank — 1, Montclare — 1.

Stats: Violence in 2 choices, Stealth in 2 choices, Deceit in 2 choices.

Katya Vetrova · Choices checked July 2, 2026

Relationships in this episode: Volpe, Frank, Montclare

1
- Remember.31diamonds
  - This choice helps Mercy uncover the mystery of her father's death and make sense of her upbringing
- Shake it off.free
  - no effect
2
Christ, Volpe…
- Separate the men forcibly.free
  - +1 Violence
- Distract them.free
  - +1 Stealth
- Say something charming.free
  - +1 Deceit
3
- Ask Volpe if he’s been watching you.19diamonds
  - Volpe: relationship
  - Volpe: romance or friendship
- Comfort Frank after his scare.19diamonds
  - Frank: relationship
  - Frank: romance or friendship
- Shake your head.free
  - no effect
4
Iver Johnson
- She wanted it.19diamonds
  - MC will carry a weapon
  - Frank: relationship
  - Volpe: relationship
- She didn’t want it.free
  - no effect
5
- Stay and hear Frank’s response.free
  - no effect
6
Whiskey
- Sniff.free
  - no effect
- Take a sip.free
  - no effect
7
But I’m not about to ask that. Not yet.
- Practice sleight-of-hand.free
  - +1 Stealth
- Strengthen your wrists.free
  - +1 Violence
- Remark on the sly bartender.free
  - +1 Deceit
8
I could ask him about Malone.
- Place a hand on his hand.19diamonds
  - Montclare: relationship
  - Montclare: romance
- Why Malone?4diamonds
  - You talk with Moncler
- No, not now.free
  - no effect
End of episode 4